The Decline of Baseball

After the Giants and Dodgers abandoned Newinvalidate the entire 162-game season and that
York City and moved to California in 1958, theseveral teams in one division might have better
changes in Major League baseball accelerated. Inrecords than the top team in the other division.
1961 the original Washington Senators moved toInstead of a World Series between the two best
Minneapolis, took the name "Twins," and ateams, that could lead to two second-rate teams
replacement team that became known as thesneaking into the World Series. However, the
"Senators II" started up in Washington. Theowners, contemplating the additional revenues
Senators II lost two out of three games just asfrom two pre-World Series division championships,
the original Senators had done, and after aplus television rights, all at premium prices,
decade of perpetuating the "Washington-first inpooh-poohed the protests of the purists.
War, first in Peace, last in the American League,"The first couple of years the teams with the best
tradition, they moved to Dallas in 1972 andrecords happened to win the playoffs, but in
became the Texas Rangers.1972, although Pittsburgh had a better season-long
Another new American League team started-uprecord, Cincinnati won the playoffs. In 1973, the
in Los Angeles in 1961, took the name Angels,Mets limped to the head of the National League's
played in Wrigley Field-not the one in Chicago, theeastern division with the fourth best record in the
one in Los Angeles-and in 1965, seeking to identifyleague. Instead of a first rate Cincinnati team,
with the entire state rather than just L.A.,which won seventeen more games than the
changed their name to the California Angels. InMets, playing a first-rate Oakland team, Oakland
1997, after purchase by Disney, seeking toplayed a tarnished anti-climax of a World Series
identify with Disneyland, they changed their nameagainst the team with the ninth best record in
to the "Anaheim Angels." In 2005, after being soldbaseball. The predictions of the purists had come
by Disney and seeking to identify with the entiretrue.
Greater Los Angeles Metro Area, they changedThe fourth and most damaging of 1969's three
their name to the "Los Angeles Angels atdamaging events began with the St Louis
Anaheim."Cardinals trading Curt Flood, their Golden Glove
In 1962, the National League expanded to tencenterfielder and perennial .300 hitter, to
teams, adding the Houston Colt .45s (after thePhiladelphia. Flood refused to go and, with the
gun that won the West) and the New York Metssupport of the player's union, filed a million dollar
who, in their first season, lost 120 games--theSherman anti-trust suit against the Major Leagues
twentieth century single season record. Cynicalseeking triple damages and abolition of the
New Yorkers, still mourning the loss of the Giantsreserve clause. The reserve clause, part of all
and Dodgers, claimed that "Mets" was aorganized baseball contracts, forbade ballplayers to
shortening of the medical term for the suddenleave the team with which they'd signed without
and rapid spread of a malignant growth.that team's approval even after the term of the
In baseball, just as in the stock market, everycontract ended.
decline is interrupted by occasional spirited rallies,If dissatisfied, a player's only recourse was to
which convince the gullible that all will soon be well."hold out" and refuse to play. Holdouts' salaries
After losing 737 games in their first sevenwere suspended and they were not permitted to
seasons and finishing tenth five times and ninthplay for any other team. The original idea had
twice, in 1969 the metastasizing Mets became thebeen to prevent financially strong teams from
Miracle Mets. With Tom Seaver and Jerrybuying championships by cherry-picking star
Koosman pitching, Ed Kranepool and Bud Harrelsonplayers from financially weak teams. Owners,
in the infield, Cleon Jones and Tommy Agee in thehowever, used the clause for their own rather
outfield, they won the National League pennantthan Major League Baseball's benefit by keeping
and beat the Brooks Robinson, Frank Robinson,salaries unfairly low.
Boog Powell, Jim Palmer, Dave McNally, MikeAlthough the Supreme Court, decided against
Cuellar Baltimore Orioles four games to one in theFlood five to three, the players' union persisted
World Series.and in 1975 got the reserve clause nullified on
In spite of the Miracle Met, four damaging 1969other grounds. Leverage in salary negotiations
events re-accelerated baseball's decline:immediately shifted to the players and salaries
First, four new teams were added, the Montrealexploded.
Expos and San Diego Padres in the NationalHaupert's The Economic History of Major League
League, the Seattle Pilots and Kansas City RoyalsBaseball reports that average salaries went from
in the American League. Expansion from sixteen$45,000 in 1975 to $289,000 in 1983 and to $1.2
teams to twenty-four in eight years brought inmillion in 2002. To put the scope of the change
more money, but diluted the supply of top-levelinto perspective, the $100,000 Joe DiMaggio and
players by adding two hundred newcomers to theTed Williams were paid in the 1940s and 50s,
four hundred Major Leaguers.adjusted for inflation, would have been $700,000
Although the leagues initiated a draft systemin 2008. In that year, the Yankees paid Alex
under which each of the existing teams supplied aRodriguez $28 million, twenty times what Williams
list of players they were willing to have takenand DiMaggio combined were paid in their primes
away by the four new teams, most of the twoand $6 million more than the combined salaries of
hundred newcomers ended up on the new teamsthe entire Florida Marlins team whose won-lost
along with players the existing teams were willingrecord of 84-77 was close to the Rodriguez/
to sacrifice. The Pilots and Padres each lost oneYankee record of 88-74.
hundred ten games in their first year and itOnce top players became able to switch teams
became common for six or eight teams to loseat will, the fears that had led to establishing the
ninety or a hundred games a season. Thatreserve clause were realized. Rich teams raided
lowered the overall quality of play, set up manypoor teams for players and cut the longevity and
one-sided games, and compromised theidentification of individual players with individual
comparability of sixty years of religiously compiledteams. That ended the Golden Years feeling of
and studied Major League statistics.closeness and shared responsibility among players,
Again in 1969, the two Major Leagues wereowners, fans and sportswriters. Players went on
divided into eastern and western divisions of sixstrike, owners conducted lockouts and the
teams each. To determine the leagueeconomics changed. Baseball, for fifty years
championships and decide who played in the WorldAmerica's secular religion, became just one more
Series the leagues began holding five game postbig business whose owners had fallen out of
season playoffs. Purists protested that that wouldtouch with their customers.